19329: Permission for storey and a half style extension to an existing dwelling, internal and external alterations to same dwelling and all associated site works
Aghabeg, Corries, Muinebheag
DecisionRefused
Decided03 March 2020
Application typePERMISSION
Source documents6
Site
What is on file
1refusal reasons0conditions8nearby records
Decision details
Core application dates and identifiers from the public planning record.Planning analysis
Refusal reasons and planning conditions extracted from the public decision file.Refusal reasons
Design
The proposed extension is incompatible with the existing farmhouse dwelling in form, scale, and appearance, negatively impacting its character.
Section 11.6 of the Carlow County Development Plan 2015-2021The design of the proposed house extension represents an incompatible addition to the existing farmhouse dwelling which is not sensitive to the house in its form, scale and appearance, and would unfavourably affect the character of the house by reason of its overall size, form, and height.
Conditions
No conditions
No conditions are on record for this application yet.
Source documents
Original council portal records and source PDFs where available.- Application fileApplication file on www.eplanning.ieSource portal
- Planners ReportSource: carlowcoco.eplanning.ie / 6f6ade8f-d3e1-4bd4-a3d0-0b8370040195.PDF / Document 74468Source PDF
- Planners ReportSource: carlowcoco.eplanning.ie / 5c0cce3d-61f2-4c3d-8ba1-31c9b59e6ae2.PDF / Document 75502Source PDF
- Planners ReportSource: carlowcoco.eplanning.ie / 52b1688e-98f7-4592-a215-b0701450072d.PDF / Document 75503Source PDF
- Further Information RequestSource: carlowcoco.eplanning.ie / 3dc36ffa-db8d-496f-9e04-3196a2f608bd.PDF / Document 73376Source PDF
- AppealSource: carlowcoco.eplanning.ie / 083e7eaf-4ec1-46c1-ba7f-853600c32d96.PDF / Document 74467Source PDF
Nearby precedent
Similar nearby applications linked to this planning decision.- 2560068A quarry development, at Coolnapish, Bagenalstown, Co. Carlow on behalf of Milford Quarries Ltd., comprising of: (a) The excavation of 114,000 m3 of sand and gravel (no processing), over an extractive area of 2.11-hectares at an average annual rate of circa 40,000 tonnes, over a 5-year period (i.e. circa 190,000 tonnes overall). (b) Construction of a new splayed entrance and access road. (c) Construction of a perimeter berm within a 5m-wide strip immediately adjacent to and outside the extractive area, all within the overall development area of 2.49-hectares. (d) Construction of a wheelbath. (e) All associated site works and services to facilitate the development. A five-year term is sought for extraction and an overall development period of eight years is sought to allow for preparatory site works and completion of restoration works. A Natura Impact Statement has been prepared in respect of the proposed development and is submitted with the Application / 2.7 km away / 24 April 2026Refused
- 22236To construct a four bedroom dormer bungalow and single storey domestic garage and associated site works. All to be serviced by suitable effluent treatment system. / 3.4 km away / 24 November 2022Refused
- 2611For PL21/373 for the construction of a single storey type dwelling with effluent treatment system & percolation area with new vehicular entrance and all associated site works / 3.7 km away / 13 May 2026Refused
- 2360184Retention permission for the following, 1. The construction of a single storey extension to an existing domestic garage, 2. the unauthorised change of use of the afore mentioned domestic garage to use as a habitable dwelling, 3. the unauthorised installation of a septic tank & percolation area, 4. the construction of a domestic store and a boiler house, and all associated works / 4.0 km away / 11 October 2023Refused
- 17105Development consisting of the construction of a three storey square extension at the rear of the existing house, which is listed on the record of Protected Structures, the construction of a single storey link between the extension and the existing house and attendant site works / 4.2 km away / Not recordedRefused
- 2560349The construction of a single storey dwelling, wastewater treatment system, a bored well, extend existing access lane and upgrade entrance and all associated site development works / 4.8 km away / 08 January 2026Refused
- 1718Development on the Barrow Navigation (The River Barrow) through the townlands of: NEWACRE, NEWGARDEN, BESTFIELD or DUNGANSTOWN, STRAWHALL, CARLOW, GRAIGUE, CLOGRENAN, KILLEESHAL, BALLINABRANNAGH, BALLYGOWAN, PART OF TOMARD UPPER (ED Rathornan), TOMARD UPPER (ED Rathornan), PART OF TOMARD LOWER (ED Clogrenan), RATHORNAN, RATHVINDEN, BALLYKNOCKAN (Idrone West By), LEIGHLINBRIDGE, RATHELLIN, DUNLECKNY, MONEYBEG, KILREE, SLIGUFF, KILGRANEY (Idrone East By), CLOMONEY (Idrone East By), BALLYELLIN and TOMDARRAGH, BALLYTEIGELEA (Idrone East By), BORRIS, BALLYNAGRANE, COURNELLAN, BALLYKEENAN (St. Mullin's Lower By), HARRISTOWN, TINNAHINCH, KNOCKEEN, CARRIGLEAD, BAHANA, St. MULLIN'S The proposal consists of the development of a multi-use shared leisure route (Blueway), approximately 115 Kilometres (KM) in length, on the existing navigation towpath, which is a National Waymarked Way. This will include tailored surface finishes, information, directional and safety signage, and all other associated ancillary works. The route traverses parts of counties Kildare, Laois and Carlow. The route commences in Lowtown, County Kildare, passes through County Laois and finishes in St. Mullins, County Carlow. Approximately 52KM of the route is in County Carlow, 16KM in County Laois and 47 KM in County Kildare. The proposal will involve works to or within the curtilage of the following protected structures: An Environmental Impact Statement and Natura Impact Statement have been prepared in respect of the project and are submitted with the application. / 4.8 km away / 21 February 2018Refused
- 18333For the construction of a dormer type dwelling, domestic garage, septic tank & percolation area, new entrance, bored well and all associated site works / 4.8 km away / 04 April 2019Refused