19446: The construction of a dormer style dwelling, wastewater treatment system, bored well, new entrance and all ancillary site works.
Sragh, Ballon, Co. Carlow
DecisionRefused
Decided12 June 2020
Application typePERMISSION
Source documents3
Site
What is on file
1refusal reasons0conditions8nearby records
Decision details
Core application dates and identifiers from the public planning record.Planning analysis
Refusal reasons and planning conditions extracted from the public decision file.Refusal reasons
Rural Housing Need
Applicants failed to demonstrate a genuine housing need for a rural one-off dwelling. They already hold permission for another house in the rural area (ref 06/472) and own a second rural property, conflicting with CDP policy restricting subsequent one-off dwellings.
County Development Plan Policy Sections 2.7.1.3 and 2.7.5applicants have not demonstrated a genuine housing need, having previously been granted permission for a house in the rural area pursuant to permission reg. ref. 06/472 and having indicated ownership of another house in the rural area.
Conditions
No conditions
No conditions are on record for this application yet.
Source documents
Original council portal records and source PDFs where available.- Application fileApplication file on www.eplanning.ieSource portal
- Notification Of DecisionSource: carlowcoco.eplanning.ie / E2b64d2c-54f7-4f63-b92f-2390f2df5d61.pdf / Document 90357Source PDF
- Planners ReportSource: carlowcoco.eplanning.ie / 7c4fe594-e6cd-4cd8-8983-de04717afc4a.pdf / Document 90356Source PDF
Nearby precedent
Similar nearby applications linked to this planning decision.- 22224For PL16/384 for the construction of proposed dwelling within an existing unfinished housing development and completion of same. The proposed development (21 no. housing units in total) shall consist of 2 no blocks of 4 no. three bedroom dwellings, 2 no. single storey dwellings, 1 no block of 3 no. two-storey three bedroom dwellings, 8 no. two-storey three bedroom semi-detached dwellings and all associated works. Permission is also sought to complete 5 no. commenced houses as follows: complete 4 no. two story three bedroom dwellings with proposed alterations to layout and design of same, permission to complete roads and services to same, permission to complete 1 no detached 4 bedroom dwelling with proposed alternation to layout and design of same, permission to complete roads and services to same, and all associated site works. / 2.1 km away / 23 September 2022Refused
- 25602032no. 2 bed two storey semi detached dwellings adjacent to existing housing development under construction and associated site works. Additionally permission is sought for the relocation of 2no. 3 bed semi detached dwellings being a revision to previously granted permission 16384 / 2.1 km away / 05 September 2025Refused
- 2560089Modifications and realignment of the front boundary and footpath, the addition of 8 no. additional car parking spaces together with all associated site works and landscaping / 2.1 km away / 04 June 2025Refused
- 18192The development will consist of the construction of a two storey residence, new vehicular entrance and driveway, advanced wastewater treatment system, soil percolation area and associated site development and boundary works. The total floor area of the house will be 264.7m2. The total site area is 0.19 Hectares/ 0.48 acres / 2.2 km away / 06 July 2018Refused
- 2560327The construction of a fully serviced single storey residential dwelling, a detached domestic garage, alterations to an existing entrance and all other associated site works / 2.3 km away / 18 March 2026Refused
- 2360029Planning permission is sought for (a) the construction of a single-storey dwelling, (b) revisions to previous grant of planning permission PL21/221 consisting of the relocation of permitted entrance to serve as a shared entrance for proposed and existing dwellings, (c) connection to public foul sewer and mains water and all associated site development works / 2.4 km away / 28 April 2023Refused
- 2460090Retention of partial conversion of existing garage permission granted under planning reference 0074 & 04132 to a two bedroomed self-contained flat with a living/kitchen area and shower/toilet room. Connection to mains water and existing septic system and all ancillary site works / 2.6 km away / 11 June 2024Refused
- 17362Retention at this address of existing one and half storey domestic garage/storage building which has been converted to study/recreation room (46.45m2), and retain new build single storey extension and lobby comprising dining/living area (39.72m2). / 2.9 km away / 05 September 2018Refused